Decoding Idea Validation: Your Top Questions, Answered

As product veterans, innovation consultants and mentors for the startup industry, we come across many common questions that we are beginning to compile as a resource to help others that are starting on their journey. 

These questions are beyond-a-doubt questions that come up in almost every consultation. If your question isn’t here, please let us know and we will answer it in the next series!

01. How do I know whether my idea is worth pursuing?

While we thrive on exploring cutting-edge technologies and fresh ideas, determining whether an idea is worth pursuing is an enigma that remains unsolved. We understand the yearning for a definitive answer to this question.

However, we believe that if you can address and provide substantiating evidence for a series of crucial questions, your idea may hold promise.

These questions consider the fundamental aspects of a successful product and serve as a compass, directing your focus and effort. 

Here are the questions that can guide you:

1. Desirability: Do you have customers who are genuinely interested and willing to pay for your idea?
2. Viability: Can your idea generate a return on investment? Is there a viable business model that supports its long-term sustainability?
3. Feasibility: Do you possess the necessary resources, including a capable team, adequate funding, the right technology, and sufficient time, to bring your idea to life?

If you can definitively answer these questions, your idea may indeed be worth pursuing. However, it is crucial to resist the temptation to plunge straight into the build phase.

This is a common pitfall. Instead, take the path of validating your idea before fully committing to it. We recommend exploring The Product Foundation Kit, which offers the Ultimate Idea Screening Checklist.

Remember, idea validation is an essential first step in the journey towards creating a successful product. It helps you mitigate risks, fine-tune your strategy, and ensure that your efforts are focused on ideas with the greatest potential for success.

‍

02. How will I know when an idea is validated?

Idea validation is not a simple ‘yes’ or ‘no’ proposition.

I want you to imagine a journey with several interconnected steps.

Think of it as climbing a staircase. Each step represents a milestone in the validation process, moving you closer to determining the viability of your idea. 

While individual steps may not provide a definitive answer, when you zoom out and look at the overall progress, you start to see leading indicators.

These indicators help you gauge the potential success or failure of your idea and guide you in making informed decisions.

It's an iterative process that allows you to learn, adapt, and refine your idea, increasing the chances of reaching a validated and market-ready product.

‍

It's important to recognise that the definition of success or validation may vary depending on different perspectives. What may be considered successful for one person or entity may not be the same for another.

Investors, for instance, often evaluate success based on the market potential and the return on their investment. They want to see the ability to capture a significant market share and generate substantial revenue. 

On the other hand, for a new startup founder, success may start with selling just one product, then gradually scaling up to 10, 100, and beyond. Each step along the way builds confidence and helps them progress on this interconnected staircase of validation.

To determine what success metrics are relevant to your idea, it's important to define clear goals and objectives. These metrics should be specific to your industry and business.

Once you have identified these metrics, rapid experimentation becomes a powerful tool to test the assumptions that underpin your idea.

You can do that by narrowing down and conducting small-scale, real world experiments to capture data, and draw insights.

Be sure to make sure to align your idea with the success metrics as this is how you steer and make informed decisions on how to move forward.

Our methodology and rapid experimentation process allows you to learn, adapt, and iterate, ultimately increasing your chances of reaching a validated state.

‍

How can I test my idea without investing too much money?

Testing and validating your idea without investing too much money requires a shift in mindset and a focus on lean, efficient methods.

Many people incorrectly believe that idea validation requires a large budget for building an MVP, creating prototypes, or hiring external help. 

At Cultivate, we introduced a game-changing concept called Minimum Testable Products (MTPs) that revolutionised the way we test and validate our own ideas and our clients.

MTPs allow you to launch your own experiments quickly and effectively. But first, it starts with changing the pre-conceived notion that validating an idea requires building a functional MVP.

Now, let's talk about effort.

MTPs are designed to be lean, fast, and affordable.

We have developed a collection of methods specifically tailored for creating MTPs that serve as tools for testing assumptions and gathering valuable insights from your target audience.

With our curated database of methods, you can easily find the right approach based on your specific needs. So if you're looking for low-cost methods or low-effort techniques, our database has you covered. It's a treasure trove of proven strategies to help you validate your ideas efficiently and effectively.

If you’re new to our world of MTPs or the Cultivate Methods Database, we have some incredible resources that will help you!

‍